Top row — Supreme Court: Claudia DePeyster, Brian Gotlieb, Jacqueline Williams. Bottom row — Civil Court: Juliet Howard, Chidi Eze, Janice Chen. Images by Phaats Photos / Roger Archer; Janice Chen photo via her campaign.
As the judiciary continues to shape policy and society, the outcomes of New York City’s judicial elections are increasingly consequential. Voters from all boroughs selected newly promoted Supreme Court justices and first-time Civil Court judges in the latest cycle.
The Trump years demonstrated the impact judicial power has on everyday realities. Now, local voters are more attuned to the importance of court races, knowing that judges interpret the laws that govern their lives. This year’s election results reinforced that trend.
Why Courts Need Our Attention
Even though the media often spotlights Congress or City Hall, it’s the courts that determine housing, contracts, and constitutional questions in NYC. Judges hold much influence over justice and fairness in our communities.
The 2023 judicial races highlighted a renewed understanding that local court elections matter as much as national ones.
Supreme Court Winners by Borough
Manhattan (1st Judicial District)
- Judy Kim — Democratic Party
- Suzanne Adams — Democratic Party
- James G. Clynes — Democratic Party
- Deborah A. Kaplan — Democratic Party
Brooklyn (2nd Judicial District)
- Carl J. Landicino — Democratic Party
- Betsy Barros — Democratic Party
- Jill R. Epstein — Democratic Party
- Maria Aragona — Democratic Party
- Derefim Neckles — Democratic Party
- Claudia Daniels-DePeyster — Democratic Party
- Norma Jennings — Democratic Party
- Jacqueline Williams — Democratic Party
- Brian L. Gotlieb — Democratic Party
Queens (11th Judicial District)
- Sandra Perez — Democratic Party
- Ira R. Greenberg — Democratic Party
- Gary F. Miret — Democratic Party
- Frances Y. Wang — Democratic Party
- Soma S. Syed — Democratic Party
Staten Island (13th Judicial District)
- Matthew P. Blum — Republican Party
Civil Court Winners
The Civil Court is often the front line for legal issues like housing and contracts. The new judges are a testament to New York’s professional depth and diversity.
Manhattan (New York County)
- Eric J. Wursthorn — Democratic Party, 3rd Municipal Court District
- Onya Brinson — Democratic Party, 7th Municipal Court District
- Lisa S. Headley — Democratic Party, 8th Municipal Court District
- Judge of the Civil Court – 9th Municipal Court District (Certification pending)
Bronx County
- Katherine A. O’Brien — Democratic Party, 1st Municipal Court District
- Lauvienska E. Polanco — Democratic Party, 2nd Municipal Court District
- Shekera Anessa Algarin — Democratic Party, Civil Court, Bronx County
Kings County (Brooklyn)
- Janice Chen — Democratic Party, Kings County
- Marisa Arrabito — Democratic Party, Kings County
- Sheridan Jack-Browne — Democratic Party, 2nd Municipal Court District
- Chidi A. Eze — Democratic Party, 4th Municipal Court District
- Juliet P. Howard — Democratic Party, 6th Municipal Court District
- Duane Frankson — Democratic Party, 7th Municipal Court District
- Dagmar Plaza-Gonzalez — Democratic Party, 7th Municipal Court District
Queens County
- Sheridan C. Chu — Democratic Party, Queens County
- Indira D. Khan — Democratic Party, Queens County
- Oma D. Phillips — Democratic Party, Queens County
- Juliette-Noor Haji — Democratic Party, 1st Municipal Court District
- Thomas G. Wright-Fernandez — Democratic Party, 2nd Municipal Court District
- Eve Cho Guillergan — Democratic Party, 2nd Municipal Court District
- Gail A. Adams — Democratic Party, 4th Municipal Court District
- Fania Jean — Democratic Party, 4th Municipal Court District
- Jennifer A. Tubridy — Democratic Party, 5th Municipal Court District
Richmond County (Staten Island)
- Matthew J. Santamauro — Democratic Party, 1st Municipal Court District
Looking Ahead in the Judiciary
These election results are a testament to New Yorkers’ focus on transparent and equitable courts, ensuring justice at every level for all residents.
With new judges bringing diverse perspectives, the city’s courts are set to play a vital role in upholding democracy and protecting rights as national debates intensify.
Subscribe to NYC Politics for political updates, exclusive interviews, info on candidates, legislation, and coverage of the 2026 NY State elections.
